[QUOTE="Paul Carmichael"] Sorry, but that's not a SMIDSY. That's a case of your lad being inexperienced. It sounds like there was a legitimate gap and the driver used it. The lad was creating an extra lane that the driver couldn't be expected to know about.[/QUOTE] Like I said, I think they were both liable to some extent. There may have been a "legitimate gap" but that doesn't entitle the car driver to pull out through it without looking. The law would appear to agree - most accidents of this kind seem to have been settled on a proportionate basis.